‘The Girl in the Fireplace’: A Rant
So, I just finished ‘The Girl in the Fireplace’ and it still bothers me. Actually, it bothers me even more because, I hadn’t realized that the first time they met she was seven years old, and the second time they met — when she was most likely still a teenager — is when she kissed him. I thought they kissed when she was older, and after they had met several times before. I think I am most upset that the Doctor not only enjoyed the kiss, but he bragged about kissing the future Madame De Pompadour, like she wasn’t just a seven year-old less than five minutes ago. If this episode didn’t have that underlying creep factor with the Doctor happily kissing a teenage girl he first met and last saw when she was prepubescent, a minute ago, it would be a really good episode.



